+1 (339) 337-9616 info@clainetrcm.com Mon - Fri, 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM ET
ClainetRCM Get a Free Audit
Medical Billing

CMS-1500 vs UB-04: Which Claim Form to Use and When

CMS-1500 vs UB-04: professional vs institutional claims, who files each form, the 837P and 837I equivalents, key fields and the errors behind most rejections.

ClainetRCM Billing TeamNovember 12, 20265 min read

CMS-1500 vs UB-04: Which Claim Form to Use and When

CMS-1500 vs UB-04 is the first question in any billing workflow: is this a professional claim or an institutional claim? The answer decides the form, the electronic transaction, the codes required and the payment rules that apply. Using the wrong one, or filling the right one incorrectly, is a fast route to rejection.

Quick answer: The CMS-1500 (version 02/12, maintained by the NUCC) is the professional claim form, used by physicians, non-physician practitioners, therapists in private practice, ambulatory surgery centers, independent labs and many suppliers. Its electronic equivalent is the 837P. The UB-04 (also called the CMS-1450, maintained by the NUBC) is the institutional claim form, used by hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, home health agencies, hospices, rural health clinics, FQHCs and other facilities. Its electronic equivalent is the 837I. When a physician sees a patient in a hospital, the physician’s service goes on a CMS-1500 and the hospital’s facility charges go on a UB-04.

CMS-1500 vs UB-04 at a Glance

CMS-1500UB-04 (CMS-1450)
Claim typeProfessional claimInstitutional claim
Electronic version837P837I
Maintained byNational Uniform Claim Committee (NUCC)National Uniform Billing Committee (NUBC)
Fields33 numbered items81 form locators
Service codesCPT and HCPCSRevenue codes, plus CPT/HCPCS for outpatient services and ICD-10-PCS for inpatient procedures
Setting identifierPlace of service codeType of bill
Typical usersPhysicians, NPPs, ASCs, independent labs, ambulance and DME suppliersHospitals, SNFs, HHAs, hospices, RHCs, FQHCs, CMHCs

Who Uses the CMS-1500

  • Physicians and non-physician practitioners in any setting
  • Therapists, psychologists and counselors in private practice
  • Ambulatory surgery centers, for facility claims to Medicare
  • Independent clinical laboratories and imaging centers
  • Durable medical equipment and ambulance suppliers

Who Uses the UB-04

  • Hospitals, for inpatient and outpatient facility charges
  • Skilled nursing facilities, home health agencies and hospices
  • Rural health clinics and federally qualified health centers
  • Community mental health centers and comprehensive outpatient rehabilitation facilities
  • End-stage renal disease facilities and other institutional providers

Key Fields on the CMS-1500

ItemWhat it holdsCommon error
1aInsured’s ID numberID that does not match the card
11Insured’s policy group; “NONE” for Medicare when no other coverageLeft blank on Medicare claims
17 and 17bReferring or ordering provider and NPI, with qualifierMissing qualifier or NPI
21Up to 12 ICD-10-CM codes (A to L)Non-specific or invalid codes
24BPlace of serviceOffice POS used for a hospital outpatient visit
24DCPT/HCPCS and modifiersMissing or misplaced modifiers
24EDiagnosis pointerPointer to the wrong diagnosis
24JRendering provider NPIGroup NPI used as rendering
32Service facility locationMissing when required by the payer
33 and 33aBilling provider and NPIIndividual NPI used for a group

Key Fields on the UB-04

Form locatorWhat it holdsCommon error
FL 4Type of bill, such as 111 for an inpatient admit-through-discharge claimWrong frequency digit for a corrected claim
FL 6Statement covers periodDates that do not match the services
FL 14 and 15Priority of admission and point of originMissing on inpatient claims
FL 17Patient discharge statusWrong status affecting DRG payment
FL 31 to 36Occurrence codes and spansMissing required occurrence dates
FL 39 to 41Value codesMissing values the payer requires
FL 42Revenue codesRevenue code without a required HCPCS code
FL 44 to 47HCPCS, units and chargesUnits that do not match the revenue code
FL 56Billing provider NPINPI not enrolled with the payer
FL 67Principal diagnosisSequencing error
FL 76Attending providerMissing NPI

Our guides to type of bill 111 and revenue code 0510 go deeper on UB-04 coding.

Professional and Facility Billing for the Same Visit

Many encounters produce two claims. When a physician treats a patient in a hospital outpatient department, the physician bills the professional service on a CMS-1500 with a facility place of service, such as POS 22 or 19, and is paid the lower facility rate. The hospital bills its facility charges on a UB-04 with the appropriate type of bill and revenue codes. Provider-based clinics work the same way, which is why patients may receive two bills for one visit.

Quick Decision Guide

  • Is a facility billing for its own resources, such as rooms, nursing, supplies or equipment? Use the UB-04.
  • Is an individual clinician or a professional group billing for the clinician’s work? Use the CMS-1500.
  • Is a supplier billing for equipment, lab tests or transport? Usually the CMS-1500, unless the supplier is part of a hospital.
  • Not sure? Check how the entity is enrolled with the payer. A provider enrolled as an institutional provider bills on the UB-04; one enrolled as a physician, practitioner or supplier bills on the CMS-1500.

Paper vs Electronic Claims

Most payers require electronic claims, and Medicare requires them except for small providers and certain exceptions. When paper is allowed, use the official red-ink forms; many payers return photocopies and outdated versions. The NUCC and NUBC publish updated instruction manuals, so check them each year for field changes.

Frequently Asked Questions

The CMS-1500 is used for professional services billed by individual providers and suppliers. The UB-04 is used for institutional services billed by facilities.

Yes. CMS-1450 is the official name of the UB-04 institutional claim form.

For Medicare, ASCs bill facility services on the CMS-1500 or 837P. Some commercial payers require the UB-04, so check each contract.

The ASC X12 837P professional claim. The UB-04’s electronic version is the 837I.

Physicians bill their professional services on the CMS-1500. Facility services billed by hospitals, including some services in provider-based clinics, go on the UB-04.

Final Thoughts

The CMS-1500 vs UB-04 choice is simple once you know whether the service is professional or institutional, but the details inside each form decide whether the claim is clean. Our medical billing services team bills both claim types every day, and our guide to clean claims in medical billing explains the habits that keep rejections low.

ClainetRCM

Written by

ClainetRCM Billing Team

ClainetRCM is a Boston-based revenue cycle management company specializing in medical billing, coding, credentialing and denial management for healthcare providers across all 50 states. Our AAPC and AHIMA certified team works inside your existing EHR, files claims within 24 to 48 hours and reviews every AR bucket on a 14-day cycle.

Keep reading

Related articles

Free revenue audit

Find out what your practice is losing to denials.

Send us 90 days of remittance data and we will show you, line by line, which claims were underpaid, denied, or never worked, and what it would take to recover them. No cost, no obligation, and you keep the report either way.

No setup fee. No long-term contract. Pricing from 2.29% of monthly collections.